It is often suggested that, in order to avoid CGT and/or Transfer Duty, it is advisable to sell only the Bare Dominium (that is, the physical property) of a fixed property into a trust structure, retaining the usufruct (right of use) in the hands of the original owner. If the owner is relatively young, the usufruct has a high value and the bare dominium has a low value, hence the apparent avoidance of tax. What are the problems with this scheme? The tax in the long run, bearing in mind the time value of money, works out about the same,…
Investing in Property
I had a meeting with a guy who had this great scheme to save tax. He’s an investor in residential property and was going to register various properties in his own name, his wife’s name and his childrens’ names so that each of them was in a business doing less than R1m turnover. Then he was going to register each of the businesses as a micro enterprise and pay turnover tax. Tax on R999 999 turnover = R14 120 Brilliant! It doesn’t work because of the anti-avoidance rule in the 6th Schedule of the Income Tax Act. This says that…
Let’s say that your VAT registered company bought an office block as an income earning going concern from a VAT vendor. The deal complied with s11(1)(e) of the Value Added Tax Act and was zero rated. Your company then converted the offices into residential units. What are the VAT implications of this? My understanding is that when the conversion has been completed and the residential units become available for letting, the original unpaid Input VAT should be added to the Output VAT and paid over to SARS. If only part of the commercial property, say, 60%, being less than 95%,…
We have just made our 7th move in the 7 years since we sold our house and became nomads. What are the advantages of renting rather than buying your home? Buying Home owning is expensive. You pay Transfer Duty, conveyancer’s fees, rates, levies, insurance, interest, repairs, maintenance. You buy with your heart and not your head, so you probably do not get the best deal, which makes the bond repayments higher than they should be. You are stuck there and can’t just up and move away when things go wrong or you feel like a change. You end up doing…
So, your VAT registered company is planning to buy a mixed use (commercial and residential) property from another VAT registered company. This would typically be shops on the ground floor and flats on the first floor. How does the zero rating for a going concern work in this case? I had a lot of trouble answering this one, but eventually found an excellent opinion by the Tax Faculty, of which I am a member. The article was written by Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr. s11(1)(e)(ii) Value Added Tax Act … where the enterprise or part, as the case may be, disposed of…
By “swallow” I’m referring to people who live in the Northern Hemisphere and travel South every year (typically to a coastal town) to enjoy our summers and avoid the worst of their winters. Now, interestingly, I asked myself the title question while talking to a South African who has lived and worked in Abu Dhabi for 17 years and heads South during the height of their summer to cool off in our winter weather! He and his wife are planning to build a “swallow’s nest” in Mossel Bay. It will not be rented out and will be used only by…
What is ring fencing? Under certain circumstances an assessed loss may only be deducted from future taxable profits earned as a result of the same trade. An example, which is the one I want to deal with here, is when a natural person earns a salary and also rents out property. If the property rental business makes a loss, there is a possibility that the loss cannot be deducted from the salary income for tax purposes but can only be deducted from future rental profits. So, what are those circumstances? See s20A of the Income Tax Act. Ring fencing only…
It is interesting that, although it is the buyer who pays the conveyancing fees, it is the seller who is entitled to choose the conveyancer. Now, let’s say that you are a property investor and you have a good relationship with a particular conveyancer. As an experienced investor you don’t care whether your offer is accepted ot not, because you can always make an offer on another property. Now you are in a strong bargaining position. Simply change the OTP to state that you are entitled to appoint a conveyancer of your choice. There is no way that this little…
A couple who booked a meeting with me were not sleeping at night because they had been doing more than R1m a year turnover from their two multi-unit AirBnB premises and they weren’t VAT registered. What does the law say about this? As soon as you exceed R1m a year VATable turnover, you must register as a VAT vendor. If you don’t, SARS may deem you to have done so and demand the VAT portion of all your invoices, even if you didn’t add VAT. This is what they were panicking about. The legislation is open to various interpretations and…
This question is only relevant when the liability date could fall either into the previous tax year or the new tax year of the seller. Let’s say that the seller’s tax year ends on 28 February. The Offer to Purchase was signed by both parties on 15 January 2023. The supensive clauses were satisfied on 5 February 2023. The transfer was registered at the Deeds Office on 25 March 2023. From a CGT point of view, when were the proceeds of the sale received by or accrued to the seller? (see 3(a) Eighth Schedule, Income Tax Act) My view, as…
Let’s say your trust owns an asset such as fixed property. s42 allows you to interpose a company between the trust and the asset without Transfer Duty and without CGT. But let’s say you had that structure and, for some reason, wanted to remove the company so that the trust owned the asset directly. Is there a provision similar to s42 that allows this without taxes? The answer is no. In fact a lot of people held fixed property in a company which they owned personally. This was because they could sell the shares in the company and Transfer Duty…
If you are looking for an investment property, my answer is a definite no. The reason is, that you make your profit when you buy, so, if you don’t buy well, you don’t make a profit and your dreams of building a significant property portfolio will die. So, how can I say that an off plan purchase is not a good buy? Simply because it is at market value and a good buy is always below market value. The better you buy, the more successful you will be, so, get into the habit of putting in stupid offers and not…
In my discussions about Trusts, I frequently have a go at attorneys who are self-confessed cut and paste experts. I point out that the more you cut and paste, the more likely you are to produce garbage. In fact, I dedicated a whole chapter on this in my book “16 Steps to Wealth”. But this week, I came across another cut and paste idiot. Me!! When we agreed to lease our residence in Pezula, Knysna, it was from the owners, who would move out so that we could move in. I offered to draw up the lease and they agreed.
It is a general rule in tax that transactions between connected persons are deemed to be at market value. Typically, this arises when someone sells their fixed property or shares in a private company to their trust. The question then arises “Who must do the valuation?” and the Income Tax Act and Transfer Duties Act are silent in that regard. They simply say that SARS may challenge any valuation. This means that the seller can determine the market value. And that raises the question “On what basis must the asset be valued?” Generally, companies are valued on their last signed…
The sale of property always attracts VAT or Transfer Duty but never both. Under special circumstances, the sale can be zero rated. This is when you buy a commercial property renting business as a going concern. Developers are invariably VAT registered, so the VAT that they charge you replaces Transfer Duty. They often advertise this as “No Transfer Duty” and then bury the VAT in their selling price, so you don’t see it. In the above example the Transfer Duty (after taking the VAT out of the price) would have been R44 963, but the VAT in the selling…
I have often said that it is cheaper to rent than to own your own home. I have also often said that the best form of investment is residential property for rental. So, how can these two apparently contradictory statements both be correct? Let’s first talk about renting rather than owning. Why is it cheaper? Because the people that we rent from did not make good investments. Their ROI can be as low as 3,5%. Usually they are either renting us a property that was at one time their residence and had been bought for that purpose, or they were…
I get so many people wanting to buy a shelf trust because they need to sign an offer to purchase urgently. Why? Because the seller has given them a deadline! What’s wrong with this scenario? Firstly, they should be buying the property in a company of which their new trust will become the owner. They clearly haven’t read my book “16 Steps to Wealth“ Then, they are not following one of the basic principles of successful property investment – you must not want anything badly. If you get the wants, you will not buy well, and don’t forget that…
When planning an Asset for Share swap using the s42 provisions in the Income Tax Act, you will see that the shares have to be new issues, not existing shares. As we invariably want all of the shares to be owned by a trust, we find it best to use a new company. The way an Asset for Share swap works is the new company issues 100% of its shares to the trust in return for an asset or assets (usually fixed property). There is no tax against this transaction. No CGT, no Transfer duty, no tax. There are, however,…
I was chatting to a client on Zoom and trying to do some quick arithmetic at the same time. I didn’t do too well! She had R35m which she wanted to lend to an investment company that would be owned by a new trust. The question was. How much tax would she pay as a result of s7C of the Income Tax Act. s7C says that she would have to charge the company interest on the loan at least at the official rate which is currently 5,25%. Because the company deducts the interest from its taxable income, that’s a negative…
You know, for a Pr(Eng); CA(SA); I can sound pretty dumb at times. Like when a client recently asked me if I was familiar with Velocity Banking. Nope, never heard of it! So he then went to some lengths to explain this miraculous method of paying off your mortgage bond in no time flat. Um, surely all you’re saying is that if you put all of your excess income over expenditure towards your bond, then, because that extra reduces the capital, it also reduces the interest and the interest on the interest? Yes, well, if you put it like that,…